Prayer is a frequent theme throughout the Gospels. Again and again, we
find Jesus speaking to His followers about the importance of prayer, styles
of prayer; He even leaves His disciples a model of prayer (the "Our Father"
or "Lord’s Prayer").
In this week’s Gospel, Jesus continues His teaching on prayer with a
parable addressed "to those who were convinced of their own righteousness
and despised everyone else." The key to reading the parable correctly lies
in this initial statement. The parable is a contrast between two very
different spiritual attitudes: self-righteousness and the humility that
comes from honest self-recognition.
It is no accident that the first character we encounter is a Pharisee. In
the Lord’s time, Pharisees by and large believed themselves to be
spiritually better than everyone else. They trusted in themselves, in their
religious accomplishments, as the basis of their righteousness in God’s
sight. Their conviction was that they saved themselves; therefore, they did
not need God’s forgiveness. Thus, the Pharisee in the parable — the poster
boy of self-righteousness — lacked any sense of sin. He may not have been
"greedy, dishonest, adulterous," but he is proud, conceited, boastful and
judgmental. There is plenty in his life that needs contrition and
confession.
The paradox is that the Pharisee prides himself on not being "like the
rest of humanity." In saying this, though, the Pharisee separates himself
from the Lord Jesus, who, by His baptism, deliberately identifies Himself
with sinners. In fact, Jesus has come to save only those who acknowledge
their sinfulness and their inability to save themselves.
Enter now the other character in the parable: the tax collector — one of
many who appear in the Gospels. The gravity of the tax collectors’
sinfulness is offset by their willingness to listen to the Gospel and to
welcome Jesus into their homes. They remain receptive, contrite and humble.
They are honest sinners.
St. Luke portrays this tax collector in the light of other figures in his
Gospel: lepers and the friends of Jesus at Calvary. All of them stand off at
a distance — a sign of humility and reverence. The tax collector refuses
even to raise his eyes to heaven, signifying his shame and repentance. All
he can do is hope for a mercy and forgiveness that he did not merit. Because
of this spiritual attitude, the tax collector truly prayed, while the
Pharisee, on the other hand, sought to inform God how good he already was.
Jesus’ words remind us that God’s relationship with us is not a matter of
listing our actions in terms of good versus evil. Whoever engages in a
process of calculation when dealing with God runs the risk of coming up with
the wrong result. God alone can tell who is close to Him. The judgment
spoken by Jesus certainly means that the Pharisaic attitude is the wrong way
to approach God; it is the humble and penitent recognition of one’s sinful
condition that gains a person access to the Lord. The key to spiritual
growth is the honest admission that we are all like the tax collector: we
all need God’s mercy, for we all have sinned. As Jesus tells us, it is this
humble self-acknowledgment, and the consequent turning to the Lord that
follows from it, that wins for us the grace of being exalted.
Fr. deLadurantaye is director of the Office of Sacred Liturgy, secretary
for diocesan religious education, a professor of theology at Notre Dame
Graduate School and in residence at the Cathedral of St. Thomas More in
Arlington.