WASHINGTON — The Trump administration Oct. 6 issued interim rules
expanding the exemption to the contraceptive mandate for religious employers,
such as the Little Sisters of the Poor, who object on moral grounds to covering
contraceptive and abortion-inducing drugs and devices in their employee health
insurance.
The contraceptive mandate was put in place by the Department of
Health and Human Services under the Affordable Care Act.
While providing an exemption for religious employers, the new
rules maintain the existing federal contraceptive mandate for most employers.
Today’s decision is a “return to common sense, long-standing
federal practice, and peaceful coexistence between church and state,” according
to the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.
Cardinal Daniel N. DiNardo, Archbishop of Galveston-Houston and president
of the USCCB, and Baltimore Archbishop William E. Lori, chairman of the USCCB’s
Ad Hoc Committee for Religious Liberty, offered the following joint statement
in response:
“The Administration’s decision to provide a broad religious and
moral exemption to the HHS mandate recognizes that the full range of
faith-based and mission-driven organizations, as well as the people who run
them, have deeply held religious and moral beliefs that the law must respect. Such
an exemption is no innovation, but instead a return to common sense,
long-standing federal practice, and peaceful coexistence between church and
state. It corrects an anomalous failure by federal regulators that should never
have occurred and should never be repeated.
“These regulations are good news for the Little Sisters of the
Poor and others who are challenging the HHS mandate in court. We urge the
government to take the next logical step and promptly resolve the litigation
that the Supreme Court has urged the parties to settle.
“The regulations are also good news for all Americans. A
government mandate that coerces people to make an impossible choice between
obeying their consciences and obeying the call to serve the poor is harmful not
only to Catholics but to the common good. Religious freedom is a fundamental
right for all, so when it is threatened for some, it is threatened for all. We
welcome the news that this particular threat to religious freedom has been
lifted, and with the encouragement of Pope Francis, we will remain ‘vigilant,
precisely as good citizens, to preserve and defend that freedom from everything
that would threaten or compromise it.’”
President Donald Trump had pledged to lift the mandate burden
placed on religious employers during a White House signing ceremony May 4 for
an executive order promoting free speech and religious liberty, but Catholic
leaders and the heads of a number of Catholic entities had criticized the
administration for a lack of action on that pledge in the months that followed.
From the outset, churches were exempt from the mandate, but not
religious employers. The Obama administration had put in place a religious
accommodation for nonprofit religious entities such as church-run colleges and
social service agencies morally opposed to contraceptive coverage that required
them to file a form or notify HHS that they will not provide it. Many Catholic
employers still objected to having to fill out the form.
The HHS mandate has undergone numerous legal challenges from
religious organizations, including the Little Sisters of the Poor and Priests
for Life.
A combined lawsuit, Zubik v. Burwell,
made its way to the U.S. Supreme Court, where the justices in May 2016
unanimously returned the case to the lower courts with instructions to
determine if contraceptive insurance coverage could be obtained by employees
through their insurance companies without directly involving religious
employers who object to paying for such coverage.
Senior Health and Human Services officials who spoke to reporters
Oct. 5 on the HHS rule on the condition of anonymity said that the exemption to
the contraceptive mandate would apply to all the groups that had sued against
it. Groups suing the mandate all the way to the Supreme Court include the
Little Sisters of the Poor, the Archdiocese of Washington, the Diocese of
Pittsburgh, Eternal Word Television Network and some Catholic and other
Christian universities.
In reaction immediately after the 150-page interim ruling was
issued, religious groups that had opposed the mandate were pleased with the
administration's action.
Michael Warsaw, EWTN chairman and CEO president, said the
television network's legal team would be "carefully considering the
exemptions announced today and the impact this may have on our legal challenge
to the mandate, but we are optimistic that this news will prove to be a step
toward victory for the fundamental freedoms of many Americans."
Mark Rienzi, senior counsel at the Becket Fund, told reporters in
a telephone news conference an hour after the rule was released that it is a
"common sense and balanced rule and a great step forward for religious
liberty."
He said the rule "carves out a narrow exemption" and
keeps the contraceptive mandate in place for those without moral or religious
objections to it.
He noted that it does not provide immediate relief for those
groups who had challenged it, such as the Little Sisters of the Poor, which
Becket represents. They will "still need relief in courts," he said,
but was confident now that it would happen.
"We've traveled a long way," he added, of the multiple
challenges to the contraceptive mandate in recent years, which he described as
an "unnecessary culture war fight."
Julie Asher contributed to this story.